The Roosters’ coach, Trent Robinson, remains optimistic about Lindsay Collins’ recovery from a minor hamstring strain, suggesting he could return as soon as next week. However, the outlook isn’t as positive for Sandon Smith and Billy Smith, who are facing prolonged absences due to injuries.
Despite this setback, there is some positive news as halfback Sam Walker has been given the green light to play. Despite being categorized as having a concussion after the match against South Sydney, further examination revealed it was more of a neck issue. Walker showed no symptoms on the field after a collision during the game.
Robinson supports the decision-making process regarding concussions being left to independent doctors, as they are impartial. He also approves of the system that has previously allowed players like Tom Trbojevic to return early under certain circumstances after being cleared by medical professionals.
Robinson noted that under normal circumstances, Walker wouldn’t have been taken off the field, and even if he had, he likely would have returned to play. However, given the situation, categorizing it as a category 1 concussion seemed excessive, and both the NRL and the team agreed, which was reassuring as it could have impacted the game negatively.
Robinson expressed appreciation for the independent process involving doctors, highlighting that team trainers may not catch everything and could be biased toward their own team. Having an impartial doctor make decisions in such cases is valuable.
He acknowledged that while rare, there have been instances where the categorization of injuries like Walker’s has been downgraded after the game, suggesting a need for balance in such assessments.
Walker’s clearance to play against the Panthers is a positive development for the Roosters, although Collins will be unavailable due to a left hamstring injury sustained last week.
Robinson mentioned that Lindsay Collins’ hamstring injury is relatively mild, showing positive signs of improvement, although he’s not yet fit for play. However, there’s optimism as he’s already resumed running, indicating a potential return next week.
Unfortunately, the news is less encouraging for Sandon Smith and Billy Smith. Sandon suffered a significant injury to his left elbow, specifically a medial ligament injury, while Billy faced another stroke of bad luck with a serious ankle injury during the NSW Cup.
Sandon’s resilience was highlighted by Robinson, as he sustained the injury in the first half but continued to play on after halftime with his elbow strapped. Despite his determination, he’s expected to be sidelined for 4-6 weeks due to the injury’s severity.
Billy’s injury occurred when he landed awkwardly after contesting a high ball, resulting in a chipped piece of bone in his ankle. He underwent surgery on Monday night to address the issue, leading to a longer recovery period of a few months.
The Roosters aim to break an eight-game losing streak against the Panthers, who dominated them with scores of 48-4 and 30-6 in their previous encounters last season. However, Nathan Cleary, whom Robinson hailed as the best player globally, will be absent due to a hamstring injury sustained last week.
Despite Cleary’s absence, the Panthers have demonstrated their ability to succeed without him, as seen in their victories over the Roosters at Allianz Stadium last year.
Robinson admitted the team’s past performances against the Panthers haven’t met their standards. With the upcoming match being played at their home ground, the Roosters are determined to deliver a better performance, providing clear motivation for the team.