After losing four Grand Finals, including a recent 60-point loss to Brisbane in 2024, Longmire, who is currently in his 15th season, is under a lot of scrutiny.
Despite leading the Swans to a premiership in 2012, there have been questions about his capacity to change tactics, especially at the MCG, where the team has a poor Grand Finals record.
Sydney CEO Tom Harley has publicly supported Longmire, highlighting his dedication while ruling out any immediate plans for a coaching succession. Despite speculation that long-time assistant Dean Cox could step in, Harley asserts there is no formal transition plan. Cox, who recently turned down the West Coast head coach position, remains a potential successor, but for now, Longmire retains control.
Former Swans coach Paul Roos has expressed concerns about Longmire’s tactical approach, specifically his difficulty in adjusting to the larger MCG, which has affected Sydney in critical games.
Analysts like Kane Cornes have suggested that rival clubs might consider pursuing Longmire, given the uncertainties surrounding several AFL coaching roles.
Longmire’s future hinges on his ability to improve the Swans’ strategy and win a long-awaited premiership as the 2025 season draws closer, particularly without seasoned player Luke Parker. Longmire’s job with Sydney is in jeopardy due to the lack of a formal succession plan and growing outside interest.