The Cincinnati Reds find themselves in a curious position as the 2024 trade deadline approaches. With the expanded playoffs offering a glimmer of hope, the temptation to contend might be strong. However, the reality is the team still has some holes to fill. To acquire those pieces, some veterans might need to say goodbye. Here are 4 Reds who could be on the trade block:
1. Mike Moustakas (1B/DH):
Moustakas, a former All-Star, hasn’t lived up to his hefty contract. Injuries have hampered his production, and his on-base percentage leaves a lot to be desired. A contender looking for a veteran bat with postseason experience could be a good fit, but the Reds might need to eat some money to move his contract.
2. Nick Castellanos (OF):
Castellanos is another big-name veteran whose production hasn’t quite matched his salary. While he’s still a solid hitter, his power numbers have dipped, and his defense is a liability. A team looking for a right-handed bat with pop could target him, but again, the Reds might have to absorb some financial responsibility.
3. Tyler Mahle (SP):
This one might sting for Reds fans, but Mahle could be a valuable trade chip. He’s a solid mid-rotation starter who eats innings and has postseason experience. A team looking to bolster their pitching staff down the stretch or in the playoffs could be a perfect fit for Mahle. The return for him could be a package of young prospects to help the Reds build for the future.
4. Amir Garrett (RP):
Garrett’s fiery fastball and strikeout potential make him an intriguing option for a team needing bullpen help. However, his control issues can be a concern. A team with a strong bullpen coach who can help him refine his command could unlock his full potential. In return, the Reds could land a young arm with upside or a player who can fill a specific need.
The Bottom Line:
Trading away these veterans would be a tough pill to swallow for Reds fans, but it could be necessary to build a sustainable winner. The acquired assets could accelerate the team’s rebuild and pave the way for a brighter future. Ultimately, the decision rests with the Reds’ front office, who must weigh the cost of contention in 2024 against the long-term health of the franchise.